I think that the first important thing to look at, before we even start to look at what gifts we are giving (and how much they do, or don’t cost), is to look at who we are giving gifts to.
Sometimes the list gets pretty extreme. I have friends in different parts of the country who give gifts to their DRY CLEANERS for goodness sake. I’m not saying that it isn’t nice to think of various folks, just that you need to do a sanity check on how many people you are gifting.
Some people that you give gifts to probably wouldn’t really notice if you stopped. I don’t think that the Drycleaner would hold it against you if they only got a card
Others, like girlfriends or extended family, might actually be glad for you to initate a conversation about scaling back on gift giving. After all, if you give them a gift then they also have to spend time, thought and money getting a reciprocal gift. Not having to worry about it may actually be a relief. You’ll never know unless you bring the topic up!
So where do I stand currently on the whole gift giving issue?
Well, in my immediate family-ie sibilings and parents, we have decided to just give gifts to the children. So right now that means that I have 2 gifts to buy on my side, and 1 gift on DH’s side. But I don’t feel right not getting anything for my mom, dad and mother-in-law, so for the Grandparents I make a food basket-Until this year I’ve also been doing it for all four of my siblings anyway. I think this year I think they are just going to get one or two very small munchies instead of a full basket. Or I may just stop the siblings all together.
DH and I have a group 3 other couples, all with kids, that we hang out with a lot. The standard, started before we moved up here, was to give gifts to the children but not the adults. Well, that is 7 children! Last year around this time I started telling everyone that I was going to make each family a large bucket of caramel corn, and then each of the children was going to get a small token type gift, under $5. I knit each of the girls 2 fuzzy wristbands, and I bought each of the boys a dollar store umbrella and stenciled their name on it with a paint pen. I felt a little guilty when the Christmas party came, because Princess and Buddy received gifts that appeared to cost much more-but I’m sticking to my guns. I want the whole thing to downscale, and I was totally honest with everyone ahead of time about what I would be spending.
I will probably do a very small gift for each of the nursery school/daycare providers for Buddy (8) and Princesses teacher (1). If I have extra I’ll give a token to the mailman, trash guys, and busdriver, but I don’t plan to stress on it.
Personally, I feel I do a bit less than most folks, but even so that is 26 people, if you count the mail, trash and busdriver! And that isn’t even talking about DH and the kiddos.
Shopping for 26 additional folks can really put some extra stress and strain on your holidays. Could I opt out of even more? Probably. I don’t think that the nursery school/daycare staff would think anything if I only gave them a card (-8) and I could totally skip the mail, trash and busdriver (-3) bringing it down to $15. But most of those folks get a small batch of homemade cookies and the like, so it is pretty easy to make an extra batch or two and cover everyone.
I enjoy thinking about the holidays, doing some shopping and making some gifts, but I don’t want the effort to turn the entire season into a frazzled mess. I’m pretty happy with who I am doing things for and am starting to generate a plan to prevent overload. More on that later!







{ 13 comments… read them below or add one }
Mommy forgot the DH’s traditional gift for the kids. It started with just our own kids (and I honestly don’t know where I got the idea). I started buying an annual (date/yr) “Silver Eagle” US dollar coin, for each of the kids. It has since evolved into one for all the kids in our family and friend’s families (up to almost 20 now). I shop for them on ebay and coin shops early in the year (got this year’s last month) and it’s “frugal” to buy in bulk – Tube of 20 or half a tube of 10. This year’s crop ended up being a tad over $10 a piece. They really are beautiful coins and will be a valuable piece of history as the kids grow up.
Dh
What do you put in your food baskets for the grandparents? Great ideas for the kids in your circle of friends!
In my husbands extended family we draw names for the gift exchange. That helps, but the list still gets huge.
Thanks for talking about all this now, it is making me think and plan a little sooner than usual!
As this family grew, we siblings decided first to just give to the kids, then we eliminated that, too. (There are 11 cousins on my side–I have four of those children.) Nobody misses it. On my husband’s side, there’s just his brother, wife and one child so we do exchange with them. Besides, the baby is only a year old, so it’s fun to buy stuff for him. Or make stuff! I don’t even exchange with friends, although if I’m invited to a holiday party I bring something.
I loved the gift you sent last year. It was very helpful. This year I shall be in micronesia for the Christmas season. Please do not send a gift. After you kids were grown, I rediscovered the importance of the true meaning of Christmas–Ethel and I shall go to Midnight Mass–that should be enough.
Hey Jenn That is so sensible about limiting gifts as it just gets out of hand. I’m like you, 22 gifts, NOT including the dry cleaner
Next year I am scaling down and getting rid of siblings.
good post
Rinty from frugal living
I have many friends who are teachers and they actually DON’T like getting gifts from kids… too many apple figurines
also many of them said they don’t like to recieve baked goods – not knowing what is in it, or conditions of homes etc… I know that sounds weird, but they just didn’t feel comfortable. They said they would appreciated a $5 -$10 gift cert to say, starbucks, movie coupons or something. Most teachers would just like a card or note of appreciation.
You give gifts to the trash guys, mailman etc? I don’t think that is expected. I don’t expect my “customers” to give me christmas gifts… and I do hard manual labor.
This gift giving can get ridiculous. I just can’t give to everyone.
DH-yes, you do make sure all the kiddos get their silver dollars. I hope all the recipients realize how special they are
Amanda-Good point about the gift cards-and I have tons of mypoints built up that I can send in and redeem for gift cards. So basically free gifts!
Also, it isn’t necessary to give to the trash guys or mailmen, but both give us pretty good service. Our trash guys will even park the truck, come up to the house and get the trashcan if I’ve forgotten to put it at the curb. That is well beyond what is required. And the mail guy hand delivers packages to the doorstep, rather than just sticking a note it the mailbox and making me drive down to the post office, which I appreciate. The point is, it is nice to try to remember such folks, but not necessary. So therefore I refuse to stress myself out over giving them things, but am willing to show some extra appreciation by whipping up an extra batch of cookies when I’m already doing a marathon cookie day anyway!
Most teachers today spend a lot of their own money to decorate and stock their classrooms. So gift certificates to craft stores, office supply stores, and bookstores are especially appreciated by many (or at least the ones I know)
Jenn said:
I don’t think that the nursery school/daycare staff would think anything if I only gave them a card
Nope, we don’t mind cards at all. Red Lobster gift cards are especially nice.
LOL
Mrs Warren-ha ha
You are much more likely to see some cookies or caramel corn. . ..
Have you tried using the gift wheel mentioned in Amy Dacyczyn’s Tightwad Gazette for Christmas gift giving?
I’m going to propose to my family that we try that this year, and see how it goes.
Has anyone had experience with this?
Does it really help cut down on the crazed gift giving?
Cave Woman-sorry, I haven’t ever tried the gift wheel. I hope someone else has an answer for you!